Insurista, the comprehensive insurance blog

Full width home advertisement

Post Page Advertisement [Top]

rental car damage and liability insurance

Is a Comprehensive Car Warranty Worth It?

Purchasing a new or used car is a major investment. With costs ranging from $10,000 for an inexpensive compact to over $50,000 for a luxury SUV, most car buyers want to protect their purchase and avoid expensive repairs down the road. This leads many to consider purchasing an extended auto warranty, also known as a vehicle service contract.

Read carrefully the fine print of your comprehensive car warranty what it covers and what not

A comprehensive extended warranty, sometimes called a bumper-to-bumper warranty, is the most expansive type of coverage available. It covers nearly all mechanical and electrical components of a vehicle, with a few standard exclusions. But is this level of coverage necessary for most car buyers? Let's take a detailed look at what comprehensive warranties cover, who they benefit, and whether the cost is justified.

What Does a Comprehensive Car Warranty Cover?

Comprehensive warranties are designed to cover repairs and replacements needed for nearly all factory-installed parts on a vehicle, from the engine and transmission to the electrical, cooling, and steering systems. Coverage typically includes (Source: AAA):

  • Engine: All internally lubricated parts including pistons, piston rings, pins and cylinder heads.

  • Transmission: All internally lubricated parts including gears, input and output shafts, bearings and bushings.

  • Drive Axle: All internally lubricated parts including gears, axle shafts, universal joints and driveshafts.

  • Steering: Steering gear assembly and column, power steering pump, steering knuckle and king pins.

  • Brakes: Master cylinder, vacuum assist booster, disk brake calipers, wheel cylinders and hydraulic lines and fittings.

  • Electrical: Alternator, starter motor, distributor, voltage regulator and wiper motors.

  • Cooling system: Radiator, water pump and cooling fan motor.

  • Fuel system: Fuel pump, fuel injection system and metal fuel delivery lines.

  • Seals and gaskets: Leaking seals and gaskets on any covered parts.

  • Navigation system: Factory-installed navigation displays, GPS components and backup camera.

  • Audio system: Factory-installed stereo, speakers, amplifiers and entertainment display screens.

  • Safety systems: Airbags, seatbelt systems and collision avoidance technology like automatic braking.

  • Power equipment: Power windows, door locks, trunk release, sunroof and convertible top motors.

Comprehensive coverage provides extensive protection, but there are some standard exclusions. Wear-and-tear items like brake pads, tires, wiper blades, and alignments are not included. Additionally, maintenance services like oil changes, fluid flushes and tune-ups are the owner's responsibility. Other exclusions may include (Source: CarAdvise)

  • Damage from accidents, misuse or modifications
  • Normal deterioration from age and mileage
  • Pre-existing conditions before warranty purchase
  • Parts not installed by manufacturer
  • Certain high-tech features and trim levels
  • Damage caused by lack of maintenance

Overall though, comprehensive coverage provides extensive protection against expensive component failures. It gives peace of mind to owners who want to avoid unpredictable and costly repairs.

Pros of Comprehensive Warranties

Comprehensive warranties offer significant benefits for car buyers seeking maximum protection. Here are some of the main advantages:

  • Protects from major repair bills: Comprehensive coverage shields owners from repair costs that can easily run thousands of dollars for parts like transmissions or infotainment systems. This helps owners avoid financially devastating repair situations.

  • Covers costly high-tech features: Modern vehicles contain expensive technology like hybrid batteries, adaptive cruise control, and parking assist sensors. Comprehensive coverage protects these high-cost items that are prone to failure.

  • Covers the entire vehicle: Bumper-to-bumper coverage eliminates the need to determine exactly which complex component caused a breakdown. All repairs are covered, minus standard exclusions.

  • Provides peace of mind: For risk-averse owners who want complete protection, comprehensive warranties deliver confidence in long-term reliability. Owners don't have to constantly worry about massive repair bills.

  • Can improve resale value: Warranty coverage remaining at the time of sale adds an extra selling point. Comprehensive coverage in particular makes a vehicle more attractive to potential buyers.

For those who want ultimate protection from unexpected repairs, comprehensive warranties deliver significant benefits. They allow owners to enjoy their vehicle without worry and generally increase long-term satisfaction.

Cons of Comprehensive Warranties

While there are advantages, comprehensive warranties also have some potential drawbacks to consider:

  • Expensive premiums: Comprehensive plans cost hundreds to thousands of dollars, raising the total vehicle price by 10% or more. Premiums vary by factors like make, model, mileage and coverage duration.

  • May not be used: Statistically, most owners don't experience major breakdowns during the warranty term. So some buyers overpay for coverage they never need.

  • Repair restrictions: Warranty providers have approved repair shops that must be used. Owners can't always go to their preferred mechanic. Repairs also require authorization, and some claims may be denied.

  • Deductibles: Most plans have a per-visit deductible up to $200 that adds out-of-pocket costs for repairs.

  • Exclusions: Certain components like brake pads are not covered, so owners still pay some repair bills even with comprehensive coverage. Routine maintenance remains their responsibility.

  • Cancellation penalties: If the warranty is cancelled early, fees ranging from $50 to over $200 apply. This reduces the potential refund amount.

  • Transfer restrictions: Warranties can't be transferred to a new owner if the car is sold, reducing resale value.

  • Provider instability: Some third-party warranty companies go out of business, leaving owners without coverage. Sticking with major providers is advised.

For buyers who can self-insure repairs or won't keep the vehicle long, comprehensive warranties may not provide enough benefit to justify the cost premium.

Who Really Needs Comprehensive Coverage?

Given the high price, comprehensive warranties are best suited for certain types of car buyers or situations:

  • New car purchasers keeping the vehicle long-term: Since new car warranties are 3 years/36,000 miles at best, an extended plan protects the car after factory coverage expires for buyers who keep cars 5+ years.

  • Owners of luxury or performance models: Expensive cars have very high-cost repairs, especially for technology like air suspensions. Comprehensive coverage is appealing for Range Rover or BMW owners.

  • Used car buyers with no factory warranty: For older used cars without remaining manufacturer protection, an extended warranty provides needed peace of mind.

  • Repeat repair visitors: For owners who have already experienced multiple component failures, future breakdowns are likely. A comprehensive plan can save them money long-term.

  • Drivers keeping cars over 100k miles: Once a car has over 100k miles, parts often begin to wear out. An extended warranty keeps repair costs manageable.

  • Those with little savings: Owners without much in emergency funds benefit, since the warranty covers expensive repairs they otherwise couldn't afford.

  • Remainder of lease term: To avoid repair bills on a leased vehicle as the lease ends, a comprehensive warranty for the final 1-2 years provides protection.

For these situations, a comprehensive warranty often makes sense and provides value that exceeds the cost. But for many other buyers, more basic protection may be sufficient.

Alternatives to Comprehensive Warranties

For car buyers who don't need the full scope of bumper-to-bumper coverage, there are alternatives that provide more affordable protection:

  • Powertrain warranty: Covers the major drivetrain components only, like engine, transmission and drive axles. Costs much less than comprehensive.

  • Hybrid/electric vehicle warranty: Specific protection for expensive battery replacements in electrified powertrains.

  • Named component coverage: Covers 1-2 main systems like air conditioning or electrical. Lower cost than comprehensive.

  • Warranty on major repairs only: Covers repairs over a set amount like $800. Owners pay for minor repairs.

  • High-tech component warranty: Covers added electronics like navigation and entertainment systems.

  • Roadside assistance: Provides towing, lockout, fuel delivery and other travel benefits. Much lower cost than repair coverage.

By selecting tailored coverage plans focused on their vehicle's vulnerabilities, owners can gain financial protection while minimizing costs. More analysis should be done to determine which alternative warranty plans make the most sense at the best value.

How to Shop for Comprehensive Warranties

For car buyers who determine comprehensive protection is the right choice, it pays to shop carefully when selecting a plan. Here are some tips for finding coverage that delivers the best value:

  • Compare plans from multiple providers. Coverage and prices can vary significantly between companies. Quoting from at least 3-5 providers is recommended.

  • Consider factory-backed warranties. Automaker CPO warranties often provide the most comprehensive coverage. Third-party warranties can impose more restrictions.

  • Look for plans with $0 deductible. If you must pay a deductible, try to minimize it to $50-$100 range. High deductibles reduce the benefits.

  • Understand exclusions and limits. Look for plans with few "non-covered" parts and unlimited repair amounts. Be wary of limits on total payouts.

  • Check provider reputation. Only consider major warranty companies with excellent ratings and reviews from organizations like the BBB.

  • Learn cancellation and transfer terms. Understand any fees if you cancel early or can't transfer coverage when selling the vehicle.

  • Have an independent mechanic inspect the car first. Don't buy coverage on a vehicle with pre-existing issues or flood damage.

Taking the time to thoroughly compare plans and providers ensures customers don't overpay or get stuck with subpar coverage. Consulting a trusted mechanic beforehand eliminates the risk of inheriting someone else's problems.

Is Comprehensive Coverage Worth the Cost?

The majority of car owners are best served by more limited extended warranty plans focused on their vehicle's weak points. Comprehensive coverage offers the ultimate protection, but for most buyers provides overly expansive and expensive coverage for repairs they will never experience.

However, those who plan to keep new vehicles long term, own luxury models prone to costly repairs, lack emergency savings, or have already faced multiple breakdowns can gain tremendous value from comprehensive protection. It provides the peace of mind these owners need to fully enjoy driving their vehicle.

The ideal warranty plan matches the coverage scope and term to how long you reasonably expect to own the vehicle. Purchasing excessive coverage you don't need, or skimping on protection for an aging car you plan to keep indefinitely, are both mistakes to avoid. With smart shopping and cost/benefit analysis, car buyers can find the Goldilocks level of extended warranty protection - not too much, not too little, but just right.

Other readers were also interested in the following posts:

What is another term for comprehensive coverage?

Comprehensive Coverage and Engine Failure: Expert Tips and Analysis

What are the 3 types of car insurance?

No comments:

Post a Comment

Bottom Ad [Post Page]

Enter URL:
Powered by: