Insurista, the comprehensive insurance blog

Full width home advertisement

Post Page Advertisement [Top]

rental car damage and liability insurance

Choosing the right comprehensive coverage for your needs is an important part of finding the best car insurance policy. This guide will go over the key steps for comparing comprehensive coverage policies to help you make an informed decision. We will compare coverage types like liabilitycollision, and comprehensiveevaluate deductibles and how they impact premiums, look for common discounts that can lower your rates, research companies by looking at customer satisfaction and reviews, and finally compare premiums for the same coverage. If you continue reading this article, you'll be ready and up-to-date to choose the right policy with the best necessary coverage and nice-to-have coverage for you. Let's get started!

comparing comprehensive coverage policies is not that hard, but you need to do some research

Determine Your Insurance Needs

Before you get your hands comparing comprehensive coverage policies, you must spend some time thinking about what exactly your insurance needs are. This involves looking at both the necessary coverage required by law, as well as any additional nice-to-have coverage options you may want.

Assess Necessary Coverage

Most states require drivers to carry a minimum level of liability coverage. This covers injuries or damage that you cause to others if you are at fault in an accident. Typical minimums are:

  • $25,000 bodily injury liability per person
  • $50,000 bodily injury liability per accident
  • $10,000 property damage liability

However, experts recommend carrying liability limits that are much higher than the minimums to properly protect your assets in a major accident. Collision and comprehensive coverage are typically required if you have an auto loan or lease. Review your loan terms to confirm requirements.

Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage is also required in some states. This covers injuries to you and your passengers if you are hit by a driver with no or insufficient insurance.

When comparing comprehensive coverage policies, make sure required coverages are included.

Consider Nice-to-Have Coverage

In addition to mandatory coverage, consider these nice-to-have options:

  • Higher liability limits - Increases protection for assets
  • Collision - Covers damage to your car in an at-fault accident
  • Comprehensive - Covers non-collision damage such as weather, theft
  • Rental reimbursement - Pays for a rental car if yours is in the shop
  • Roadside assistance - Provides help with breakdowns/flat tires

Think about your budget, risk tolerance, and assets. Optional coverage adds costs but reduces financial risks. When comparing comprehensive coverage policies, look at both required and optional coverages.

Table of Minimum Coverages

Coverage Typical Minimum Limit
Liability - Bodily Injury (per person) $25,000
Liability - Bodily Injury (per accident) $50,000
Liability - Property Damage $10,000
Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist Bodily Injury $25,000/$50,000

Use this table as a starting point when comparing comprehensive coverage policies to ensure you evaluate policies that meet state minimums. Higher limits are recommended when possible.

Spending time to determine your insurance needs in terms of required and desired coverage will ensure you make an apples-to-apples comparison when evaluating policy options and premiums.

Compare Coverage Types

When comparing comprehensive coverage policies, one of the most important steps is comparing the types of coverage included. Policies can vary significantly in terms of which coverages are included and the limits associated with them. Focus on these key coverage types:

Liability Coverage

This covers injuries or property damage that you cause to others when you are at fault in an accident. Required in almost every state. Important coverage limits:

  • Bodily injury liability per person and per accident - Covers medical bills for others' injuries
  • Property damage liability - Covers repairs to others' vehicles and property

Compare liability limits across policies. Higher is better to protect assets. Umbrella policies can add extra liability coverage.

Collision Coverage

Covers repair or replacement of your vehicle if damaged in an at-fault accident. Typically required for financed/leased vehicles. Key factors:

  • Deductible amount - Higher deductible lowers premium but increases out-of-pocket costs
  • Replacement cost coverage - Will replace with new car versus current depreciated value

Compare collision deductibles across policies. Make sure replacement cost coverage is included if desired.

Comprehensive Coverage

Covers non-collision damage from theft, vandalism, weather, fire, animals, etc. Usually required by lenders/lessors. Key factors:

  • Deductible amount
  • Coverage limits - Does a cap apply?
  • Exclusions - Damage from floods, riots, etc. may be excluded

Compare comprehensive deductibles and coverage limits when evaluating policies. Make sure needed exclusions are not in place.

Policy Limits Comparison Table

Coverage Policy 1 Policy 2 Policy 3
Liability - Bodily Injury (per person) $100,000 $50,000 $25,000
Liability - Bodily Injury (per accident) $300,000 $100,000 $50,000
Collision Deductible $500 $1000 $250
Comprehensive Deductible $500 $500 $1000

Use a table like this when comparing coverage types across multiple policies. Make sure you compare apples-to-apples.

Carefully comparing coverage types is crucial to finding the right policy. Evaluate liability limits, deductibles, caps, and exclusions across multiple policies to find the best fit.

Evaluate Deductibles

When comparing comprehensive coverage policies, one key factor to evaluate is the deductible amounts. The deductible is the portion of a claim that you pay out-of-pocket before insurance coverage kicks in.

Higher deductibles reduce your monthly premiums, but increase the amount you pay for repairs before the insurance company contributes. Lower deductibles mean higher premiums, but less money you have to pay for repairs before insurance helps.

Impact of Higher vs. Lower Deductibles

Higher deductible pros:

  • Lower monthly premiums
  • Good choice if you have significant savings

Higher deductible cons:

  • You pay more out-of-pocket for repairs
  • Need ability to cover larger deductible amount

Lower deductible pros:

  • Pay less out-of-pocket for repairs
  • Good if limited savings

Lower deductible cons:

  • Monthly premiums are higher
  • Less chance of premium savings

Evaluate your budget, savings, risk tolerance and repair costs when choosing deductibles.

Deductible Impact on Premiums

Deductible Annual Premium
$250 $1,200
$500 $1,000
$1,000 $800

As this table shows, higher deductibles equate to lower premiums when comparing comprehensive coverage policies. The savings may be substantial.

Choose Deductibles Wisely

When choosing deductibles:

  • Select an amount you can afford to pay out-of-pocket
  • Consider potential repair costs for your vehicle
  • Evaluate if premium savings are worth higher deductible

Carefully compare deductibles when evaluating policies to find the best balance for your budget.

Evaluating deductibles along with the premium impact is a key part of comparing comprehensive coverage policies. Make sure you choose deductible amounts that align with your financial situation.

Compare Discounts

Most insurance companies offer various discounts that can help lower your auto insurance premiums. When comparing comprehensive coverage policies, make sure to see what discounts each insurer provides and how much you may be able to save.

Common Discounts to Look For

Some typical auto insurance discounts to ask about include:

  • Good driver discount - For a clean driving record
  • Good student discount - If teen drivers maintain a B average
  • Defensive driver discount - For taking an approved course
  • Multi-policy discount - For bundling auto with home insurance
  • Multi-car discount - For insuring more than one car
  • Anti-theft device discount - For having air bags, alarm system, etc.
  • Auto-pay discount - For setting up automatic payments
  • Affinity group discounts - For belonging to certain organizations

Make a list of discounts you may qualify for and compare eligibility across insurers.

Discount Impact on Premiums

Discount Potential Savings
Good Driver 10%
Anti-Theft Device 15%
Multi-Car 5-15%

As shown, some discounts can add up to significant savings. Maximize them when comparing comprehensive coverage policies to reduce your premiums.

Stacking Discounts

You may be able to stack multiple discounts to maximize savings, for example:

  • Good driver + Defensive driver training
  • Multi-policy + Anti-theft device
  • Multi-car + Good student

Look for opportunities to combine discounts when comparing comprehensive coverage policies.

Taking the time to understand and compare potential discounts can help you identify opportunities to save on your auto insurance. Make sure to inquire about all possible discounts when getting quotes.

Compare Premiums

The final step when comparing comprehensive coverage policies is to compare the premiums. The premium is the monthly or annual amount you pay for the auto insurance policy. Follow these tips to compare premiums accurately:

Get Quotes for Same Coverage

Make sure you get premium quotes for identical coverages from each insurer. This includes:

  • Equal liability limits
  • Same deductibles
  • Identical comprehensive and collision coverage
  • Any additional coverage like rental car reimbursement

Compare apples-to-apples to accurately evaluate premium costs.

Compare Quotes Apples-to-Apples

Use a table to compare premium quotes across insurers:

Insurer Premium Quote
State Farm $120/month
Geico $100/month
Allstate $150/month

The premium comparison will be inaccurate if the quotes are not based on the exact same coverage.

Factors Impacting Premiums

Several factors can cause premium variability between insurers:

  • Driving and credit history
  • Vehicle make, model, and age
  • Discount eligibility and applicability
  • Proprietary risk assessment models

While rates may vary, the coverage must be equal for an accurate comparison.

Evaluate More Than Just Price

Don't make your decision based on premium price alone. Also consider:

  • Reputation and reviews
  • Customer service quality
  • Claims response time
  • Years in business
  • Financial strength ratings

The cheapest premium may not mean the best service and support.

Adjust Coverage to Meet Budget

If needed, tweak deductibles, limits or coverage to get premiums in line with your budget. Just maintain required minimums.

Carefully comparing premiums is the final step to choosing the right policy with the best comprehensive coverage at the optimal price.

Research Companies

When comparing comprehensive coverage policies, it's important to research the insurance companies themselves in addition to the policy details. Look at customer satisfaction ratings and reviews to evaluate quality and service.

Customer Satisfaction Ratings

Third party organizations like J.D. Power evaluate and rank insurance companies on customer satisfaction. Key criteria assessed include:

  • Claims process
  • Estimates
  • Pricing
  • Policy offerings
  • Interaction
  • Billing process

Firms are given an overall rating. In J.D. Power's 2022 U.S. Auto Insurance Study, top scorers included:

  • Auto-Owners Insurance
  • Erie Insurance
  • State Farm

Consider rankings when comparing comprehensive coverage policies from different providers.

Policyholder Reviews

Look at reviews from actual customers online and social media. Sites like ConsumerAffairs allow customers to share reviews and ratings across factors like:

  • Claims processes
  • Rates and discounts
  • Customer service
  • Coverage options
  • Overall value

The reviews can provide insight into others' experiences with the insurer.

Complaint Ratios

Insurance providers report complaint ratios to regulators. This represents the number of complaints relative to premium dollars or policies.

  • NAIC Complaint Index - Published by National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Compare complaint ratios when evaluating insurers. A lower score indicates fewer issues.

Company Comparison Table

Insurer J.D. Power Rating Online Reviews Complaint Index
State Farm 5/5 4.2/5 0.5
Allstate 3/5 3.5/5 1.2

Use a table to compare research findings across providers when evaluating options.

Taking time to research companies can give you peace of mind regarding quality and service when choosing coverage. Consider ratings, reviews, complaints, and more.

Make Your Decision

After determining your needs, comparing coverage types, evaluating deductibles and discounts, comparing premiums, and researching companies, it's time to make your auto insurance decision.

Consider All Factors

Don't focus on just one factor when choosing a policy. Take a holistic view:

  • Coverage - Does it provide the protection you need?
  • Cost - Do premiums fit within your budget?
  • Company - Are ratings, reviews and complaints acceptable?
  • Service - Will you get quality customer service?

The best policy will excel across all considerations.

Choose Best Coverage for Your Needs

Select the provider and policy that gives you:

  • Required coverage to meet legal minimums
  • Desired optional coverage to reduce financial risks
  • Ideal liability limits to protect assets
  • Deductibles you can afford to pay if needed
  • Discounts to maximize savings
  • Competitive premiums that fit your budget
  • A reputable carrier with good customer satisfaction

Don't sacrifice important coverage to get the lowest rates.

Review Selection Checklist

  • [ ] Meets state minimum liability coverage
  • [ ] Has enough liability coverage for asset protection
  • [ ] Includes desired collision and comprehensive coverage
  • [ ] Provides other useful options like rental reimbursement
  • [ ] Offers discounts I'm eligible for
  • [ ] Provides strong financial backing
  • [ ] Positive customer reviews and low complaints
  • [ ] Offers quality customer service

Run through this checklist before making a final decision.

Trust Your Instincts

If something seems off about a company or policy, trust your gut. Keep looking until you find the right fit.

Making the right choice involves carefully weighing all factors and options. Take your time to make sure you select the perfect comprehensive coverage policy for your situation.

Review Policy Annually

Once you've gone through the process of comparing comprehensive coverage policies and selected one, it's important to review your coverage annually to make sure it still meets your needs.

Check for New Discounts

Insurance companies frequently add new discounts, change eligibility for existing ones, or alter discount amounts. When your policy is up for renewal, ask your insurer:

  • Are there any new discounts I may qualify for?
  • Have my existing discounts changed in terms of amounts or criteria?
  • Can you confirm I'm getting all possible discounts?

Taking advantage of any new ways to save can reduce your premiums.

Adjust Coverage as Needed

Consider if your coverage needs to change based on:

  • New car with different repair costs
  • Teen drivers added to policy
  • Changes in state insurance laws
  • Increase or decrease in assets
  • Higher medical costs

You may need to increase liability limits, reduce/increase deductibles, or add new coverage options.

Shop Around Periodically

Get quotes from other providers once a year or when your policy renews. Competitors may have new discounts or policy offerings that could save you money.

Review Remarketing Opportunities

If you receive a non-renewal notice, your current insurer may make you a "remarketing" offer to keep your business. Review the new price and make sure coverage still fits your needs. Consider remarketing offers alongside quotes from competitors. You have leverage to negotiate in this situation.

Confirm Any Policy Changes

If you make any changes to coverage, deductibles, vehicles etc., follow up to verify the insurer updated your policy properly. Don't assume changes were made correctly. Review documents when received.

Keeping coverage up to date saves money and ensures you have the protections you need. Add annual policy comparison and review to your checklist.


Choosing the right comprehensive coverage policy takes some work, but following the steps outlined in this guide will set you up for success. Take the time to determine your needs, compare coverage types, evaluate deductibles and discounts, research companies, and compare premium quotes. Look at the big picture including cost, service, ratings, and reviews before making your decision. The policy you select should provide the necessary protection for your situation at a competitive price from a reputable insurer. Revisit your coverage annually to take advantage of new savings opportunities and adjust as your needs change. With this approach, you can feel confident you made the right choice.

The key is not just finding the lowest premium, but finding the best value by comparing all factors. Do your homework upfront to obtain the optimal comprehensive auto insurance coverage for your needs and budget.


Q: Is comprehensive coverage required by law? 
A: No, comprehensive coverage is not required by law, but most of lenders will request you to add it along with collision coverage.
Q: How much does comprehensive coverage cost? 
A: Many factors will affect on your comprehensive coverage cost like your your car's make/model, your driving records, your age or your zip code, among others. On average, comprehensivecoverage costs $188 per year. 
Q: What does comprehensive coverage exclude? 
A: Comprehensive coverage policies may exclude certain types of damages or losses, such as arson, intentionally damage your vehicle, racing, and so on.
Q: Can I purchase comprehensive coverage without collision coverage? 
A: Yes, you can purchase comprehensive coverage without collision coverage, but most insurance companies recommend having both types of coverage for complete protection.

Other readers were also interested in the following posts:

How to File a Comprehensive Coverage Claim: A Step-by-Step Guide

How to Get the Most Out of Your Comprehensive Coverage Policy

No comments:

Post a Comment

Bottom Ad [Post Page]

Enter URL:
Powered by: